72(t) SEPP explained: early retirement withdrawals before 59½

A 72(t) SEPP lets you take IRA or 401(k) money before 59½ without the 10% penalty if you stick to the payment schedule. See the three methods, how long they last, and what breaking them costs.

Share
72(t) SEPP explained: early retirement withdrawals before 59½

The 72(t) rule allows you to take money out of an IRA or an old 401(k) prior to age 59½ without the 10% additional tax. The caveat is that you must take a series of substantially equal periodic payments (a SEPP) and stick to that schedule for years.

This guide explains how a 72(t) distribution works, the three ways to calculate it, how long it must last, what happens if you break the schedule, how it compares with the Rule of 55, and how state tax applies.

❕
General information only, not tax or financial advice. A 72(t) plan is very difficult to reverse, so you should have a qualified professional look at yours prior to the first payment.

What is a 72(t) distribution?

A 72(t) distribution is a series of substantially equal periodic payments taken from a retirement account over your life or life expectancy which will avoid the 10% additional tax on early withdrawals. The authority is IRC §72(t)(2)(A)(iv). There is no minimum age.

You'll see it referred to as the 72 (t) rule, rule 72 (t), rule of 72 (t), a SEPP or a SoSEPP. It has nothing to do with the 'Rule of 72' which is the little rule of thumb you use to work out how long it will take money to double.

Four points to keep in mind:

  • It only removes the 10% additional tax. The payments are still deemed to be taxable income.
  • It applies to IRAs, 401(k)s and 403(b)s. For an employer plan you must have left that employer before the payments can start. IRAs have no such requirement.
  • Payments must be made on an annual basis. Annual, quarterly or monthly instalments are all permitted subject to your custodian.
  • The schedule is a commitment. Section 4 details the cost of breaking it.

How do the three 72(t) calculation methods work?

IRS Notice 2022-6 sets out three qualifying methods. Any other methods are not excluded, but these three are the safe ones.

RMD method

Your annual payment is your account balance divided by a life expectancy factor and is recalculated each year. You select the Uniform Lifetime, Single Life or Joint and Last Survivor table and must use the same table each year. As your balance and age change your payment will also change.

Fixed amortization method

The payment is a level amount which will pay down the balance over your life expectancy at an interest rate of your choice. You work out the payment for the first year and that's the amount you pay every year thereafter.

Fixed annuitization method

The payment is the balance divided by an annuity factor derived from a mortality table and your chosen interest rate. It's calculated once and then it's a constant.

The interest-rate ceiling

For the two fixed methods you pick a rate up to the greater of 5% or 120% of the federal mid-term rate for either of the two months prior to your first payment. So the cap is never less than 5%. The higher the rate the larger the payment.

Which balance you use

The RMD method is generally to use the prior year-end balance. For the fixed methods, any reasonable date will do (from Dec 31 of the prior year up to your first payment date). Each SEPP is on a single account, so you can't combine balances. You can run separate schedules for separate accounts, and each 72(t) withdrawal has to come out of the account it was set up for.

Feature RMD Method Fixed Amortization Fixed Annuitization
How the Payment Is Calculated Balance ÷ life expectancy factor Level amortization over life expectancy at a chosen rate Balance ÷ annuity factor from a mortality table and chosen rate
Payment Size Lower in the example below Higher Higher, close to amortization
Can It Change? Yes, recalculated each year No, except a one-time switch to the RMD method No, except a one-time switch to the RMD method
Uses an Interest Rate? No Yes, up to the ceiling Yes, up to the ceiling
Who It Tends to Suit Someone who wants payments to follow the balance Someone who wants a predictable amount Same, with a different calculation

These are descriptions, not recommendations.

An example from the IRS

The IRS's own FAQ uses a 50-year-old with a $400k IRA and a 4% rate. First-year payments would be approximately $11,050 (RMD), $21,102 (amortization) and $22,030 (annuitisation). Applying the same factors to a $500k IRA:

Method Calculation Approximate First-Year Payment
RMD Method $500,000 ÷ 36.2 About $13,812
Fixed Amortization $500,000 ÷ 18.9559 About $26,377
Fixed Annuitization $500,000 ÷ 18.1568 About $27,538

Illustration only. Assumes age 50, the Single Life Table factor of 36.2 and a 4% rate for the fixed methods; shows first-year amounts. The RMD will vary from year to year. The factors are from the IRS example. These are not quotes.

How long do you have to continue the 72(t) payments?

IRS Rule 72(t) requires the schedule to continue for the longer of five years from the date of your first payment or until you reach 59½. It's the latter of the two, not the former.

The IRS gives two examples:

  • Start at 56 on 1st December 2024 and carry on right through to 1st December 2029 even though you'll have reached 59½ in February 2028.
  • Start at 52 on 1st December 2020 and continue until 15th February 2028 (even though the fifth anniversary is 1st December 2025).

Five years means five full years from the first payment date (not five payments). You're looking at about 9.5 years if you start at 50. 57 would be five years.

What happens if you break a 72(t) plan?

A change to the schedule is called a modification. These count as one:

  • Taking more or less than the scheduled amount
  • Making any other withdrawal from the account
  • Adding money to the account (investment gains don't count)
  • Transferring part of the balance to another plan, or rolling it over
  • Changing the method beyond the one switch the IRS allows

The penalty is severe. It's 10% of that year's distributions, plus recapture of the 10% that would have applied to each prior payment, plus interest on the deferral period. Once you've made the modification, you're no longer obliged to take the old payments and you can set up a new schedule.

What doesn't count as a modification:

  • A one-off switch from the fixed method to the RMD method. You wouldn't be able to switch back to the fixed method later.
  • Using up the account with a final payment that is less than the scheduled payment.
  • Changes as a result of death, disability or a distribution to a qualified public safety employee under §72(t)(10).
  • Gains and losses in the account.

72(t) vs Rule of 55: which one is it?

The Rule of 55 depends on leaving a job in or after the year you turn 55 and covers that employer's plan, with no fixed schedule. A 72(t) plan works at any age and on IRAs, but locks you in. Our Rule of 55 guide covers who qualifies and how to take the withdrawal.

Feature 72(t) SEPP Rule of 55 Roth Conversion Ladder
Earliest Age Any Separate in or after the year you turn 55 (50 for public safety) Any
Accounts IRAs, 401(k)s and 403(b)s The 401(k), 403(b) or TSP of the employer you left Traditional IRA or 401(k) money converted to a Roth IRA
Lock-in The longer of five years or age 59½ None Each conversion has its own five-year period for the 10% tax on converted amounts
Income Tax Yes Yes Yes, in the conversion year

How state tax applies to 72(t) payments

The payments are taxable income, and the 72(t) exception says nothing at all about state tax. Which state taxes you depends on which state you're a resident of when you receive the payment. Federal law (4 U.S.C. § 114) precludes a state from taxing the retirement income of someone who is not a resident or domiciliary of that state. Does Florida tax retirement income guide covered in the link above and the states which don't tax retirement income guide has a page comparing the states.

Florida and Texas have no state income tax, and their constitutions specifically prohibit it (Fla. Const. art. VII, § 5; Tex. Const. art. VIII, § 24-a). As an example of how a $50k withdrawal would be taxed in California and New York see the table in our rule of 55 guide.

Are you planning to change your domicile prior to the start of your payments?

If Florida is on your list, SavvyNomad can provide a Florida residential address, domicile documentation, driver's license advice and mail forwarding for life on the road or abroad. A new address in itself won't change your domicile, and this is not tax advice.

SavvyNomad

Planning to establish Florida domicile before your retirement payments begin?

SavvyNomad helps you set up a Florida residential address, prepare domicile documentation, and navigate the driver's license process, with mail forwarding for life abroad.

Explore Florida residency →

Frequently asked questions

Can you stop the 72(t) payments early?

Not without consequences, of course, until the longer of five years or age 59½. Death, disability and a public safety distribution are all exceptions as is using up the account with a smaller final payment. The one-off switch from the fixed method to the RMD method is not a stop.

Does 72(t) apply to 401(k)s or only to IRAs?

Both. For a 401(k) or 403(b) you have to have left the employer prior to the commencement of the payments and each account has its own schedule.

Are 72(t) distributions taxed?

Yes. Only the 10% additional tax is avoided. If box 7 of your Form 1099-R doesn't indicate an exception, then the IRS tells you to use Form 5329 to claim the correct one.

Can I take 72(t) payments while living abroad?

The rule is part of federal tax law, which applies to US taxpayers wherever they live. Practical questions come on top: whether your custodian will pay a 72t withdrawal to a foreign account, foreign tax and treaties, and the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion, which doesn't cover pensions or annuities.

Conclusion

A 72(t) plan avoids the 10% penalty, not income tax, and its value depends on following the schedule exactly. For the abroad angle, read how to use a 401(k) and IRA as an American expat.

​